Be Careful About Placing Too Much Trust In U.S. News College Rankings

Students and their parents got one more reason this week to be skeptical of college rankings, the most widely-used of which are published by U.S. News & World Report. Los Angeles area private school Claremont McKenna admitted it had “fudged it’s numbers” in the words of The New York Times, to try and get higher rankings. Going all the way back to 2005, the school apparently supplied false numbers for student SAT scores, a critical number in the all important rankings.

“The reliance on this [rankings] is out of hand,” Jon Boeckenstedt, DePaul University Admissions associate VP told The Times. His view echoes those of many other educators who have repeatedly complained that the rankings are less than trustworthy. In a survey conducted in 2010 by the National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC), educators were asked to evaluate the quality of U.S. News & World Report’s college rankings. On a scale of 1 to 100, the educators gave U.S. News and average raking of just 28.1.

In the fall of 2011, NACAC issued a report stating that U.S. News’ methods of using metrics to rank colleges are “essentially arbitrary.” The group followed up with a request the U.S. News & World Report integrate more meaningful metrics like student satisfaction surveys and educational attainment tests, but the magazine responded that it has no intention of changing it’s methods.

But as the Claremont McKenna incident shows, colleges and universities know that, however flawed they may be, students use the rankings when shopping for schools. A long line of abuses by colleges trying to get high rankings have included Iona College’s notorious effort to lie for years not just about SAT scores, but also about and other key metrics. One of the more intersting incidents involved Baylor University, which gave students financial incentives to re-take SAT tests, in an effort to create a higher average score.

Schools have also resorted to tactics that are shady, if not downright dishonest, to try in inflate their rankings. Among those are pushing lots of alumni to give donations of just a few dollars to inflate the percentage of old students who give, and creating lots of classes with less than 20 students – a positive point in the ratings – even if it means creating other classes that have huge numbers of students.

If you’re shopping for a school, online or on campus, the message is that, while there’s nothing wrong with looking at rankings, they’re not a completely trustworthy source of information.

A New Look At One Of Philadelphia’s Oldest Schools: Drexel University

Drexel University has gone from a well-known but perhaps a bit dowdy old Philadelphia school to an online degree powerhouse – and that’s only part of the story. The school has grown drastically in the past ten years with a widening array of academic offerings. In the process, it’s managed to change the Philly neighborhood where it’s located fro a rather scary place into a very desirable address.

Here’s a Forbes interview with current Drexel president John Fry, describing where this school is headed for the future.

Steve Jobs’ Cultural Institution

For me, the transition from the old world of PCs to Steve Jobs’ platform came only recently. One spring day I found myself at the Apple Genius Bar on 14th street, with an appointment to have my son’s Mac Book looked at. I’d given it to him two years earlier at the start of college, and the poor thing now looked like it had been run over by a truck. My son had procured yet another Apple computer, and I was looking to get this one fixed so I could start recording music on a sweet little program called Garage Band, a product that made creativity easier and more democratic, like so many other things from Apple.

It took me about 10 minutes to decide that the Genius Bar was the greatest place in New York. At a table next to me, a bunch of six year old kids played games on computers with big white screens and the iconic bitten fruit logo. Halfway across the room, a lady in her seventies was wrapped up in lessons on how to use her new Mac. Along the wall, a parade of humanity sat waiting to get their phones and other devices fixed: America, Asia, Europe, Africa – the world’s citizenry chattering, pressing buttons and rubbing shoulders.

“This place is great,” I said to the kid with the Apple badge, assigned to watch over all of us waiting to be seen. “Yeah,” he said, brushing his hair off his forehead, “To me this floor is really a cultural institution.” He’d hit the nail on the head. After all, what is culture but the sharing of information in the most elegant ways possible?

It’s easy to over-estimate the importance of what Steve Jobs created at Apple. Ride any commuter train home at night, and you’ll hear people yammering on their gleaming iPhones: “What should we have for dinner tonight? Chinese or Italian. How about Chinese…No how about Italian…No maybe Chinese….” Hardly world-changing stuff.

But it’s also easy to underestimate his accomplishment. For starters, he decoupled the words “American” and “junk” from each other for the first time in decades. Since American culture exploded across the world in the 1960’s via blue jeans and Rock ‘n Roll, and then ebbed sadly and completely, nobody has made America cooler than Apple has the past 10 years.

And that’s very important. Steve Jobs succeeded by enforcing the concept that producers should adhere to a level of excellence dictated by their customers, and not the other way around. He charged a lot for his devices, but he insisted that his company be driven by one outrageous idea: that people are not stupid. That’s a subversively democratic world view.

Many have taken issue with the “hero worship” culture built up around Jobs. It must be said, though, that he was smart enough to see how it could empower him to pursue a singular vision without caving in to the sorts of bean counters and stock traders who have mediocritized so many other American companies.

Publishers and others who deal with Apple on a business to business basis will tell you it’s not the nicest company on earth. But the consumers, who Jobs focused on relentlessly, understood that each slick new accessory he brought along did more than make them look good. It made them feel smarter and more capable. And that’s a culture America can never have too much of.

Fewer Americans Are Going To Grad School This Year

The number of Americans in graduate degree programs dropped a bit last year for the first time since 2003, according to the Council of Graduate Schools (CGS). Majors that saw the largest reductions were public administration, business and education. However, the number of foreign students enrolling in American grad school programs continued to grow.

A tough economy usually sends more people back into masters and other graduate programs. But CGS speculates that the economic downturn has gone on for so long that people are becoming afraid to leave jobs to go back to school, fearing they may not get another job when they graduate. Continued rises in the cost of graduate school are also making it tougher for people to cover tuition costs.

The ongoing rise of international grad students points to America’s continuing role as a magnet for advanced students worldwide. Other facts to emerge from CGS’ new study of trends from 2009 to 2010:

  • The number of Hispanic students in grad school grew 5%, but black student enrollments dropped by 8%.
  • New international students in U.S. grad schools increased by 4.7%.
  • Women earned 60% of all master’s degrees in the U.S. in 2009 – 2010.

Though the study did not present specific numbers on companies paying for employee’s grad school, CGS speculated the employers have tightened up on educational benefits due to difficult times. One CGS representative called the drop in American grad students a tremendous threat to U.S. prosperity.

Online Degree Programs You Can Transfer Lots Of Old Credits Into

The rules always vary a bit from one school to another. But some colleges and universities are clearly more prepared to step up to the plate and help adult students get their degrees done as quickly and cheaply as possible – by accepting as many credits as possible for previous schoolwork. Here’s a listing of online schools that are willing to help you transfer lots of credit towards a bachelor’s degree, with notes on specialized completion degrees, rules on transferring credits from community colleges, minimum grade requirements and more that you need to know.

New Report Outlines How Online Learning Will Reorder American Higher Education

Although it’s written more for educators than for students, a new report from The Center For American Progress (CAP) on the future of online learning makes for pretty interesting reading. It begins sternly with a warning that: “America is in crisis. Employers say paradoxically they cannot find the right people to fill jobs even though the country is facing its highest unemployment rates in a generation,” and then goes on to indict America’s colleges for failing to fill the nation’s employment needs. Most interestingly, perhaps, it suggests that allot of our gold-plated prestige colleges and universities in the U.S. don’t really deserve their lofty reputations. The report cites “a growing acknowledgement that many American universities’ prestige came not from being the best at educating, but from being the best at research and from being selective and accepting the best and brightest.” It echoes a oft-made criticism that private colleges, in particular, have an easy time producing successful grads because they don’t have to make any effort to serve more than the select, “cream of the crop” type students they admit.

The study goes on to call online learning a “disruptive innovation” that will continue to grow dramatically due to its ability to deliver higher education to people who have, until now, been “not able to be served or…not desirable to serve,” namely adult learners and poor or minority students.

CAP goes on to paint a fascinating, and fairly radical picture of how state universities and private colleges will both have to upend their current models of teaching and institutional management. Dealing with the rising demand for online learning will force America schools to do something they haven’t done in decades: focus mainly on teaching.

On a less convincing note, the CAP’s report goes on to propose a standards system for rating the success of schools that involves a mish-mash of “90-day hire rate plus change in salary over some amount of time divided by total revenue per conferral plus retrospective student satisfaction plus the cohort repayment rate indexed to credit scores.” That sounds a bit like taking the disastrous standards approach of “no child left behind” that has virtually wrecked America’s public secondary school system, in my humble opinion, and applying it to higher education in the U.S. You can read the report here.

Mr. Gates Holds Forth On Online Education

There’s something wonderful about how being rich can get you an opportunity to sit on a stage and say incredibly obvious things, and have people sit there and act quietly respectful. Here, the ever wisdom-filled Bill Gates opines that K-12 kids probably need to attend schools in a live classroom setting, and then follows with an explanation of how kids can be really successful if they attend schools 80 hours a week. Funny how that approach to education didn’t work out in his own case. I’m no big defender of teacher’s unions, but I’m pretty tired of hearing self-appointed saviors with no education experience try to tell us all how to fix American schools.

Online Catholic Colleges Offer A Unique Private Option

America’s 200-plus Catholic colleges have long offered an interesting alternative to students, even those who come from different religious backgrounds. Catholic schools, many of which are more than 150 years old, have national reputations in many cases (think Georgetown, Gonzaga, Villanova) and large networks of alumni – who can be helpful to a young graduate doing a job hunt.

Many of these schools like to emphasize their committment to both racial and philosophical diversity, and make a point of admitting students from different places and with differing viewpoints. At St. John’s University, a large Catholic school outside New York City, for example, less than half the students are actually Catholic.

Catholic schools also look increasingly attractive from the standpoint of cost. They’re certainly more expensive than most state schools, but if you’re looking for a private school education, you’ll find that they suddenly look very affordable compared to the other options out there. Virtually all of them have high-quality accreditation. The schools were not early leaders in terms of online education, but many of them are now catching up. Here’s a useful list of Catholic online colleges and universities.

Online Courses For Students With Disabilities

A disability should not, in most cases, prevent anyone from getting their degree online. Many disabled students, in fact, are attracted to online classes because they eliminate the need to travel to a school.

Strictly speaking, the Americans With Disabilities Act requires all colleges to offer “reasonable accomodations” to students with disablities. It is, however, mainly up to the individual student to push the school to make sure this happens.

Technologies have gradually developed that make it easier for students with particular disabilities to study online. “Screen readers” are available that create an audio version of anything on a website, so that a sight-impaired person can listen to all content (a software program is required for some versions of this, but there are also add-ons to Firefox called Click Speak and Accesibar that will do it). And many schools now make a point of providing text versions of all spoken lessons for anyone with a hearing impairment.

Many colleges have a Disabled Student Services office designed to help you get the accomodations you need. Some tips to help you succeed as you deal with them:

  • Make sure you are able to handle the class schedule you are signing up for. A typical online course requires 10 – 15 hours of class and study each week.
  • Learn about the assistive technologies out there and find out if you can get comfortable with them. Online learning requires a slightly higher level of tech-awareness than classroom study. But using assistive technologies to deal with your disability will probably require you to be just a bit more tech-friendly than the average student.
  • Be willing to speak up for what you need. The law requires that schools provide help for disabled students, but exactly how much is a bit unclear.
  • Finally, before you sign up for an online degree program, ask an admissions counselor or an academic advisor at your school to tell you exactly what has been done for disabled students there already and how broad their experience is in dealing with disabled students. Also, make sure to ask if they can provide any accomodations you may need to take tests effectively

Here’s a good overview of what to do if you are a disabled student interested in online courses.

University of Nebraska’s Online Programs Booming, But Don’t Expect To Find Tuition There Lower Than For-Profit Schools

Out in Nebraska, online learning is definately on the move. Officials of the University of Nebraska report that almost 100,000 credit hours were earned last year via online learning by students who never once set foot on campus, an almost 30% jump from last year. The school’s president, J.B. Milliken, believes that online degree programs are great for students unable to attend on-campus classes.

He also notes that the distance learning programs are great for generating revenue for UofN. That’s enhanced by the fact that the state university charges more for online learning courses than for its campus courses. Tuition rates for distance learning, have, in fact, been set at levels meant to be competitive with large private and for-profit online schools. It’s an interesting move in an environment where legislators are widely criticizing for-profits for charging students too much.

In any case, Nebraska educators intent to increase course offerings to attract even more online-only learners.